The True Price Breakdown of a Quality Roof vs. a Bargain Roof
When it comes to replacing your roof, the first question every homeowner asks is the same: “How much will it cost?”
It’s a fair question—but also a tricky one. Because while two roofing bids may look similar on paper, the long-term cost difference between a quality roof and a bargain roof can be thousands of dollars.
At A Plus Roofing, we’ve spent nearly four decades serving Maine homeowners, and we’ve seen firsthand how low-budget shortcuts end up costing far more in the long run. Let’s break down the real costs — not just the numbers you see on the estimate, but the ones that show up years later.
1. The Material Difference: Shingles That Last vs. Shingles That Fail
Bargain Roof:
Cheaper shingles may look the same at first glance, but they often contain less asphalt, weaker granules, and thinner backing mats. These cost-cutting measures make them more prone to cracking, curling, and granule loss within a few harsh Maine winters. Expect a lifespan of 10–15 years (or less) before major repairs start.
Quality Roof:
High-performance shingles like IKO Dynasty or metal roofing systems resist wind, hail, and freeze-thaw cycles far better. They’re engineered for our northern climate, featuring stronger adhesives, impact-resistant granules, and thicker mats. Properly installed, these can last 30–50 years with minimal maintenance.
Real Price Difference:
Upfront: ≈ $1,500–$3,000 more for a standard 2,000 sq ft roof.
Over Time: ≈ $10,000–$20,000 saved in avoided replacements and repairs.
2. The Labor Factor: Crew Experience and Installation Standards
Bargain Roof:
Many low-bid contractors rely on untrained labor or subcontractors paid per roof, not per hour. That often means rushed installs, poor ventilation, and skipped flashing — issues that won’t show up until leaks or ice dams appear.
Quality Roof:
Experienced crews take the time to do it right. At A Plus Roofing, every installer is trained to meet manufacturer standards for warranty-protected installs, including proper nailing patterns, flashing details, and attic ventilation.
Real Price Difference:
Upfront: ≈ $1,000–$2,500.
Over Time: Peace of mind, no warranty voids, and no hidden “do-over” costs.
3. Underlayment and Ventilation: The Hidden Heroes
Bargain Roof:
Cut-rate jobs often skip proper underlayment, ice & water shield, or ridge venting to save a few hundred dollars. Unfortunately, that’s the foundation of your roof system — and once moisture gets in, the damage spreads fast.
Quality Roof:
A proper roofing system includes synthetic underlayment, full ice & water barriers along eaves and valleys, and balanced attic ventilation. Together, these components prevent condensation, rot, and premature shingle failure.
Real Price Difference:
Upfront: ≈ $800–$1,200.
Over Time: Potentially saves you $5,000–$10,000 in structural repairs and energy loss.
4. Warranty, Insurance, and Accountability
Bargain Roof:
Low-bid roofers often disappear within a few years, leaving homeowners with no recourse when problems arise. Many also install in ways that void manufacturer warranties.
Quality Roof:
A Plus Roofing backs every installation with manufacturer-certified warranties and a 10-year workmanship guarantee. You get long-term protection from both product failure and labor issues.
Real Price Difference:
Upfront: Minimal.
Over Time: A priceless layer of protection against unexpected repair bills.
5. Total Value Over Time
|
Roof Type |
Average Upfront Cost |
Expected Lifespan |
Estimated Lifetime Cost (Repairs + Replacement) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Bargain Roof |
$6,000 – $8,000 |
10 – 15 years |
~$18,000 – $25,000 |
|
Quality Roof |
$9,000 – $12,000 |
30 – 50 years |
~$12,000 – $14,000 |
When you look beyond the bid and factor in durability, warranty, and energy savings, a quality roof quickly proves to be the more affordable choice.
Final Thought: Invest Once, Not Twice
In Maine’s climate — where heavy snow, ice, and wind are constant — your roof is not the place to gamble on “cheap.” A low-price bid might feel like a win today, but over time it’s almost always the most expensive option.
At A Plus Roofing, we believe in doing it right the first time — with premium materials, skilled craftsmanship, and a proven track record you can trust.
If you’re comparing bids and want a transparent, itemized breakdown of what’s really included, give us a call. We’ll show you exactly where your money goes — and why quality always pays for itself.