Noise, Insulation, and Comfort: Comparing Roofs for Year-Round Living
When you live in Maine, your roof isn’t just a barrier between you and the elements—it’s the front line of defense against everything from nor’easters and snow squalls to summer heat and fall rainstorms. But the type of roofing material you choose does more than determine how well your home sheds water. It directly impacts your day-to-day comfort, insulation efficiency, and even how much peace and quiet you enjoy inside your home.
In this post, we’ll compare metal roofing, asphalt shingles, and rubber roofing through the lens of noise control, insulation performance, and year-round comfort—so you can make the best decision for your Maine home.
1. Noise: The Sound of Shelter
One of the biggest myths homeowners have about roofing—especially metal roofing—is that it’s noisy. The truth? With proper installation and insulation, modern metal roofs can actually be quieter than old shingle systems.
Metal Roofing:
When installed over solid sheathing with an appropriate underlayment, a quality metal roof dramatically reduces noise from rain and hail. Unlike the old barn roofs many people picture, modern residential metal panels are designed for homes—not sheds. Homeowners often report that they hear less exterior noise after upgrading to a standing seam metal roof.
Asphalt Shingles:
Traditional asphalt shingles have a natural dampening quality. Their layered composition absorbs sound waves well, making them a consistently quiet choice—especially during heavy rainfall. However, as they age and lose granules, shingles can transfer more sound through the roof deck.
Rubber Roofing (EPDM):
On flat or low-slope roofs, rubber roofing provides exceptional sound absorption. Its dense, flexible surface minimizes noise transfer, making it ideal for commercial buildings, additions, or Maine homes with flat roof sections.
✅ Quiet Choice Summary:
-
Best for silence: Rubber Roofing
-
Best balance of quiet and longevity: Metal Roofing
-
Affordable quiet comfort: Asphalt Shingles
2. Insulation: Keeping Heat Where It Belongs
In Maine, insulation is about more than just comfort—it’s about survival through long winters and humid summers. The type of roofing you choose will affect how efficiently your home retains heat in January and stays cool in July.
Metal Roofing:
Contrary to what some assume, metal roofs don’t make your home hotter. In fact, when paired with the right attic ventilation and reflective coatings, they can improve energy efficiency by reflecting solar heat. During winter, metal roofs trap radiant heat effectively when combined with high-quality attic insulation.
Asphalt Shingles:
Shingles absorb heat, which can be an advantage in winter but less desirable in summer. Without proper ventilation, that heat can transfer into your attic, forcing your HVAC system to work harder. A Plus Roofing installs Dynasty shingles by IKO, which feature Advanced Cool Roofing Technology to help reduce heat absorption and improve comfort.
Rubber Roofing:
EPDM roofs are naturally insulating due to their rubber composition. They perform best when paired with a rigid insulation board underneath. This combination seals in heat during cold Maine winters and blocks UV rays during the summer.
✅ Energy Efficiency Summary:
-
Best winter performance: Asphalt Shingles (Dynasty Series)
-
Best reflective summer performance: Metal Roofing
-
Best for low-slope energy control: Rubber Roofing
3. Comfort: The Year-Round Experience
Comfort is the ultimate measure of a roof’s success. It’s not just about the thermostat—it’s about consistency, peace of mind, and protection through every season Maine can throw at you.
Metal Roofing:
Metal roofs excel in thermal stability and weather resistance. You won’t hear ice dams cracking or see shingles curling after a harsh winter. They also shed snow quickly, which reduces roof weight and prevents leaks during spring thaws. Homeowners often say they feel more secure during heavy storms with metal roofing overhead.
Asphalt Shingles:
Asphalt remains a dependable choice for those who value a traditional look and moderate cost. With professional installation and high-quality materials, it provides solid year-round comfort, especially for homes with attics that have been properly insulated and ventilated.
Rubber Roofing:
For flat or low-slope sections—like sunrooms or garages—rubber roofing provides consistent protection with minimal maintenance. It also reduces drafts and prevents leaks that often occur in complex rooflines.
✅ Comfort Summary:
-
Best all-around comfort: Metal Roofing
-
Most budget-friendly comfort: Asphalt Shingles
-
Best for specialized areas: Rubber Roofing
4. The Maine Factor: What Works Best Here
In a climate known for its wild temperature swings and moisture, your roof needs to be more than functional—it needs to be strategic.
-
Metal roofing stands out for homes exposed to heavy snow and ice. It sheds snow effortlessly and withstands decades of punishment.
-
Asphalt shingles offer strong insulation and a softer aesthetic that fits Maine’s historic and residential styles.
-
Rubber roofing shines on commercial or flat roof sections that demand durability and watertight performance.
No matter your choice, the installation makes all the difference. At A Plus Roofing, we’ve spent nearly four decades mastering how to insulate, vent, and seal Maine roofs for long-lasting comfort.
Final Thoughts: Comfort Is Built, Not Bought
Noise reduction, insulation, and year-round comfort all start with the right roof system—and the right team to install it. Whether you’re tired of drafts, dealing with high energy bills, or simply want a quieter home during storms, A Plus Roofing can help you choose a roof that makes comfort a permanent part of your home.
👉 Ready to upgrade your roof for true four-season living?
Contact A Plus Roofing today for a free consultation and see why Mainers have trusted us for 38 years and counting.