Metal vs. Asphalt vs. Rubber Roofing: The Ultimate Maine Comparison Guide
When it comes to protecting your Maine home from harsh winters, heavy snow loads, and coastal weather, your roof isn’t just a feature — it’s your first line of defense. Choosing the right roofing material is one of the most important investments you’ll make in your home’s long-term durability and value.
At A Plus Roofing, we’ve installed thousands of metal, asphalt, and rubber roofs across Maine. Each material has its strengths, and the right choice depends on your budget, home style, and how long you plan to stay in your home.
Let’s break down the pros, cons, and costs of each — Maine homeowner style.
🏠 1. Metal Roofing: The Toughest Roof for Maine Weather
Best for: Long-term homeowners, energy efficiency, and areas with heavy snow
Metal roofing has quickly become one of Maine’s top choices for residential and camp properties — and for good reason. It’s built to last.
Advantages:
-
Longevity: A properly installed metal roof can last 50+ years — more than double the life of most asphalt roofs.
-
Snow Shedding: Snow and ice slide off easily, preventing ice dams and roof stress.
-
Energy Efficient: Reflects sunlight in summer, reducing cooling costs.
-
Low Maintenance: Metal doesn’t crack, warp, or rot.
-
Fire & Wind Resistant: Excellent protection in Maine’s stormy seasons.
Considerations:
-
Higher Upfront Cost: Expect to pay more initially, but you’ll save in the long run.
-
Noise Factor: Without proper insulation, metal roofs can be noisy during rain or hail.
-
Aesthetic Choice: Some homeowners prefer a traditional shingle look.
Average lifespan: 40–70 years
Average cost: $10–$20 per sq. ft. installed
✅ A Plus Roofing installs premium metal panels designed to handle Maine’s coastal salt air and inland snow loads — with unmatched warranty coverage.
🧱 2. Asphalt Shingles: The Traditional Maine Favorite
Best for: Budget-conscious homeowners and classic curb appeal
Asphalt shingles remain the most common roofing choice across Maine — from Portland to Bangor and everywhere in between. They’re versatile, affordable, and offer a variety of colors and textures to fit any home style.
Advantages:
-
Affordable: Lowest upfront cost among roofing options.
-
Attractive Options: Architectural shingles mimic wood or slate for added curb appeal.
-
Easy Repairs: Damaged shingles can be replaced individually.
-
Proven Performance: Works well for most Maine homes when properly ventilated.
Considerations:
-
Shorter Lifespan: Typically lasts 20–30 years.
-
Susceptible to Ice Dams: Without proper attic ventilation, shingles can trap heat and create ice buildup.
-
Maintenance Required: May need more frequent inspections after storms.
Average lifespan: 20–30 years
Average cost: $5–$9 per sq. ft. installed
✅ A Plus Roofing uses high-quality Dynasty® and BP shingles built for Maine’s freeze-thaw cycles, backed by industry-leading warranties.
♻️ 3. Rubber Roofing (EPDM): Flat Roof & Low-Slope Specialist
Best for: Flat or low-slope roofs, garages, porches, and commercial buildings
Rubber roofing — commonly EPDM (Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer) — is an incredibly durable and waterproof option that thrives where shingles and metal can’t go.
Advantages:
-
Leak-Resistant: Ideal for flat roofs where standing water is a concern.
-
Durability: Handles extreme temperatures and UV rays without cracking.
-
Low Maintenance: Virtually maintenance-free once properly installed.
-
Eco-Friendly: Many rubber roofs are made from recycled materials.
Considerations:
-
Limited Style Options: Black membrane look isn’t for everyone.
-
Installation Expertise Required: Must be installed correctly to ensure watertight seals.
-
Best for Specific Roof Types: Not ideal for steep pitches or traditional homes.
Average lifespan: 30–50 years
Average cost: $8–$14 per sq. ft. installed
✅ Our rubber roofing systems are custom-cut and sealed on-site to protect your home against Maine’s heavy rain and melting snow.
⚖️ Head-to-Head Comparison
|
Feature |
Metal Roofing |
Asphalt Shingles |
Rubber Roofing |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Lifespan |
40–70 years |
20–30 years |
30–50 years |
|
Cost (Installed) |
$$$ |
$ |
$$ |
|
Snow & Ice Resistance |
Excellent |
Moderate |
Excellent |
|
Energy Efficiency |
High |
Moderate |
Moderate |
|
Maintenance |
Very Low |
Moderate |
Low |
|
Best For |
Long-term investment |
Budget & aesthetics |
Flat/low-slope roofs |
🧭 So, Which Roof Is Best for Your Maine Home?
-
Choose Metal if you want a roof that lasts decades, adds value, and shrugs off Maine winters.
-
Choose Asphalt if you’re focused on affordability and a classic, traditional look.
-
Choose Rubber if you have a flat or low-slope roof and want watertight performance.
No matter your choice, quality installation makes the biggest difference. A high-end roof installed poorly will fail before its time — but a well-installed roof from A Plus Roofing can protect your home for generations.
🛠 Ready for an Expert Roof Evaluation?
Whether you’re comparing options or noticing wear and tear, our Maine roofing team can inspect, recommend, and quote the best roof for your home and budget.
📞 Call A Plus Roofing today at Rob: 207-837-5669
🌐 Schedule your free roofing estimate at aplusroofing.me
Serving Maine homeowners with honesty, craftsmanship, and care for over 38 years.